We Need to Gather: November 9th, 2016

The phone kept pinging in the night, text after text, for the most part, as I glanced at them, numbers without names. I tried to sleep through them. I tried to sleep at all. I didn’t want to wake up to a world where Donald Trump would be the President of the United States.

Nov 9, 2019

The phone kept pinging in the night, text after text, for the most part, as I glanced at them, numbers without names. I tried to sleep through them. I tried to sleep at all. I didn’t want to wake up to a world where Donald Trump would be the President of the United States.

When I recognized the primary text coming from a dear friend: We need to gather, she wrote as shock and horror rippled through our collective cohort of writers, artists, teachers, therapists, booksellers and assorted others. My house, I texted back to everyone whether I knew them or not. Come to my house.

Getting ready for everyone to arrive that morning, looking out the kitchen window, I was astonished to see children going to the nearby elementary school, as if this were just another Wednesday. How could they? The world had clearly changed in some hideous way. I kept trying to imagine Hillary and Bill and Chelsea sitting across from one another this morning, stupefied as the rest of us, more so. We had been anticipating this moment, the first woman president, since Barack Obama was elected to a second term. Now! Now! Now would be our moment! Now we would have a woman president…..Now….Hilary Clinton, a Secretary of State had lost to a dumpster? (No notion then that she had lost to a lot of Russian bots, Vladimir lickspittles and assorted slimeballs.)

People straggled into my kitchen starting around ten. Everyone brought something to eat, brought wine. I made a pot of soup and cornbread. We began drinking early. What else was there to do? We moaned and bemoaned. Tears were useless. So were questions, but we asked questions nonetheless. We wrung our hands and raised our voices, bewailing the many disgusting dumpster moments. (Access Hollywood tapes? “Russia, if you’re listening…” Hovering behind Hilary like Grim Death on the debate stage, nasty women, rallying, hate, anti-Mexican, anti-Muslim, anti-NATO…) Sometimes we didn’t talk, we just regarded one another like zombies from The Walking Dead. Some stayed for hours. Some came late. All day long my local friends drifted in and out of my kitchen, well past the early dusk.

That very night I joined the ACLU and the NAACP. I bought the online subscription to the New York Times and the Washington Post. (Had previously only read the free stuff). I hoped, even if I didn’t altogether believe that surely this was a terrible error, and even if it wasn’t, then surely the dumpster was so ostentatiously corrupt that we could be rid of him in a year or so. Right?

And yet. Here we are, three years out from that day that we needed to gather, and the dumpster is still in power, still throttling the American public and the world with one ghastly shock after another, and only now, at last, three years into this nightmare, is he facing impeachment. Public hearings start Wednesday. Good. I long to see him, as the old Nixonian phrase has it, “twist in the wind.”

However, We Need to Gather, that simple text my friend sent out, became a rallying cry not just for the group of us here, but everywhere! January, 2017, the Women’s March! The outcry against the Muslim ban, the coalition broadly known as Indivisibles, the onslaught of people who protested in the capitol when they threatened to strip Obamacare from millions. We need to gather! This terrible emergency brought us together.

November 9th, 2016, I, for one, believed, hoped that the press and the courts could save us. The dumpster quickly began the process of eviscerating the courts, placing far-right judges in lifetime positions (and thus endearing himself to all those good conservatives with their good conservative values…..). He has railed at the press, threatened them, called them liars and smeared them with epithets from his limited vocabulary. But the press has endured, and gone on to truth-tell. The courts may wobble for another generation, but right now judges are (so far) not collapsing in front of corruption even if the Justice Department itself has collapsed.

But after three years, who still has the heart or strength or emotional wherewithal anymore to gather? Some of my friends have just bowed out of the news. They can’t take it. I don’t blame them. I can’t take it, but somehow I sit in front of Rachel Maddow every night and hope against hope she’ll give me some little glimmer of….

Every morning I still hate to wake up in a universe where that dumpster is the President of the United States.

Every morning I remember the Reverend Al Green.

On a visit to Memphis visit some years ago my friends took me to the Reverend Al Green’s church. This was one of the great religious experiences of my life, right up there with the Basilica of San Marco in Venice, or Notre-Dame in Paris, though Reverend Al’s was a modest church, the building undistinguished. Inside, though, the solemnity and civility, cordiality among people—those who knew each, and those who didn’t, black and white—was spiced with a sense of anticipation. (Musicians traveling through Memphis were known to forswear their hangovers, crawl out of bed and show up to play at Al Green’s church. Sure enough, you could have come just to hear the sax man.) The service, like a rock concert, had a couple of warm-up acts, preachers who had some of the congregation in the aisles, and the plate got passed again and again and everyone, moved by the spirit, was parting with their money just as fast as they could.

But when the Reverend Al got up there, he let all that electricity die down, ebb. He started out slow. Telling stories that at first seemed unconnected, anecdotes really, of sadness, loss, misery and vexation of every sort, all of the stories punctuated at the end with the phrase, I’m still here, Lord! Yes, no matter the woe, the sufferer could stand up and say, I’m still here, Lord! And before long everyone in the church (which by now was filled to capacity) was ringing, their voices in concert with Al Green’s, I’m still here, Lord! To the point where I was weeping, and I was not alone.

I think of the Reverend Al and that church when the world around me has often felt so tattered and hopeless, so frigging grim and sunk in the depraved swamps of dumpster and his minions, that my spirit sinks. I remind myself, I’m still here. We’re still here. The ACLU is still here! And the NAACP is still here! The press is still here! We have all lived through these past three years, and we’re still here, and there’s an election just one more year away.

This time, in the words of a famous rock anthem, we won’t be fooled again.  We’re going to get it right, to do it right, and on November 4th, 2020 when we need to gather, this time it will be to rejoice. Or, god help us.


  1. Patty Stephenson


  2. Sharon King

    Someday our grandchildren’s children will ask “How did Donald Trump become President? “ I don’t know the answer. It was beyond belief. I pray we survive the threat he poses and we get it right next time.

  3. nancy adair

    May I offer additions to the editor? You say, “…the dumpster is still in power.” I say, “The dumpster is still on fire, burning orange like the gateway to hell. ” You say, “the onslaught of people who protested in the capitol.” I might add, “the cowardly congressmen who prostrated in the Capitol at the altar of satan.

    I just read an article by the author of the book about Mr. Rogers. He said that America’s best neighbor was a gentle man who demanded that each of us make goodness attractive so it will survive into the next millennium (2000s). Sadly, that writer thinks that too many have been dragged into the dumpster, and our country has let Mr. Rogers down. Yet this author also says that 16 years after his death, Mr. Rogers is still revered, which kindles a glimmer of hope. God will show up. Let’s hope the lies have not made us too blind to see. I’m still here, Lord. Eyes wide open.

    • Laura Rink

      Amen to your additions! Mr. Rogers was a fixture in my childhood, and to a lesser extent my children’s. He was/is a blessing.

  4. Kathy Renner

    No wonder you are one of my favorite authors. I bow to you in sisterhood.

  5. Laura Rink

    Amen! Thanks for your words which resonate so strongly in me.

  6. Helen Worley

    Very well said, Laura. You have captured what I felt and feel. It’s hard to believe that it will four years in January that I marched with our granddaughter in DC. So much has happened, but we’re still here. Satpal won despite the huge amount of money the oil industry and others spent to try to thwart his election. There is hope! We’ll be working so we can celebrate next November.

  7. Jean

    The late Hugh Prather said, “The world cannot withstand your love.” May it be so.

  8. Victoria

    Thank you! Your blog posts are always perceptive, insightful, and compelling. Yes, we’re still here. Thanks for reminding us of the power of our community.

  9. Susan Chase-Foster

    Blessings on you for writing a heart-song of hope in the middle of our country’s current nightmare, Laura. Hearing how Reverend Al kept himself and his congregation afloat is inspiring. We’re still here and we’ll stay here. And when November 3, 2020 rolls around we’ll vote to kick the dumpster out of office, send him back to Mar-a-Lago, or better yet, prison.

  10. Annie

    Thank you, Laura. The description of your experience at Reverend Al Green’s Church was moving. Nothing is holier than to keep speaking. Our ancestors protected the story line of our history, painting an image of who we are and where we have come from.
    In this time of tremendous confusion you inspire us to be vigilant, safeguarding truth. Carol Sagan summed it up well when he described the destruction of the Alexandrian Library and a brilliant civilization. He writes in ‘Cosmos’: “It was as if an entire civilization had undergone some self-inflicted brain surgery, and most of its memories, discoveries, ideas and passion were extinguished…the loss was incalculable…how ignorant we are of our past!”
    Laura, thank you for reminders in ‘The Great Pretenders’.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest